Face-off: Rogue Ohio Bar v.s. Rep Fitness Excalibur Bar

 photo DSC00538_zps84f99821.jpg
Rogue’s red Ohio bar endcap…probably the meanest looking endcap on the market. That Matt Chan endcap looks sick too though.
 photo DSC_3504_zpsd72dfc07.jpg
Again, points to the Ohio bar in the visual department, that gold bushing doe.
 photo DSC_3506_zps53580575.jpg
Notice the finer knurl pattern on the Ohio bar. They both feel great though.
 photo DSC_3502_zps6a8b41ef.jpg
Here’s another view on the knurling.
 photo DSC00523_zps916ca2b8.jpg
The Rep and the AF Team Barbell just for comparison sake. Notice that while the AF barbell looks to have a fine knurl like the Rogue, it doesn’t feel like that in the hand. More sharktooth like…but not as aggressive.
 photo DSC00548_zpsbe1e61fd.jpg
Grooves on the sleeves are better machined on the Rogue, but the Excalibur is slightly longer.
 photo DSC00541_zps52dcc190.jpg
Black oxide vs bright zinc – they both look awesome.


  1. Do you prefer the 28 or 28.5mm diameter? I was about to pull the trigger for the Ohio until I stumbled upon the Excalibur which, from your review, may even be better. Rogue’s black oxide just looks so badass.

    1. I prefer 28mm, sounds like it wouldn’t make a huge difference but it does for Oly lifts. The black oxide does look pretty badass, but you will have to oil it up regularly to keep it looking badass. Overall, I like the Excalibur all in all better, but the knurling is better on the Ohio.

      1. As far as maintenance goes, it would go hard chrome, zinc, oxide, and bare steel. The Excalibur being bright zinc, shouldn’t require any real maintenance besides cleaning it when it gets too chalky or bloody. Oxide is like bare steel and still just needs to be oiled up every now and then.

Leave a Reply